If you’re an ice cream lover and an Earl Grey fan, this recipe is just for you! Plus, you’re looking for a new and exciting flavor to add to your ice cream repertoire? Look no further than this Homemade Earl Grey Tea ice cream recipe. 

This delicious ice cream is a perfect blend of creamy sweetness and that distinctive Earl Grey flavor that we all know and love.

Trust me when I say, this ice cream is the real deal. Creamy, smooth, and with just the right amount of Earl Grey tea, it’s the perfect treat for any occasion. 

Whether you’re serving it up alongside your favorite baked goods or enjoying it all on its own, you won’t be disappointed by this delicious flavor.

What flavor is Earl Grey Ice Cream?

If you’re a fan of Earl Grey tea, you’re in for a treat with this Earl Grey ice cream!

Bergamot orange oil adds floral, citrusy, and grapefruit notes to black tea leaves.

By steeping loose leaf tea in full-fat milk, the ice cream base with a hot cream mixture is infused with aromatic flavors, making it even more delicious.

Earl Grey ice cream is perfect as a refreshing treat on its own or paired with other desserts.

What is Earl Grey Ice Cream made of?

There are a few simple ingredients used to make this homemade ice cream, found in any big grocery store:

• Whole milk. This ingredient is essential in creating a creamy and smooth texture in the ice cream. 
  The fat content in the milk helps to create a rich and velvety base that is the perfect canvas for the other flavors to shine.
• Earl Grey tea bags. This is a key ingredient for this ice cream. Adds a unique and sophisticated flavor to the ice cream. 
  The fragrant bergamot oil in Earl Grey tea pairs perfectly with the creaminess of the milk and creates a subtle yet distinctive taste.
• Granulated sugar. Adds sweetness to the ice cream and helps to balance out the bitterness of the tea.
• Heavy cream. Adds richness and creaminess to the ice cream, making it even more indulgent and luxurious. 
  The fat content in the cream also helps to create a smooth and silky texture.
• Vanilla extract. Adds a subtle sweetness and depth of flavor to the ice cream that rounds out the other ingredients. 
  Be sure to use high-quality vanilla extract to really enhance the overall taste of the ice cream.
• Salt. This may seem like a small ingredient, but it plays an important role in balancing out the sweetness of the sugar and enhancing the other flavors in the ice cream. 
  A pinch of salt can go a long way in taking your Earl Grey ice cream to the next level.

Add-ons & Substitutions

Want to change things up a bit? Here are some easy ways to customize this ice cream.

• No tea bags on hand? Use loose-leaf early grey tea. Just strain it thoroughly with a fine mesh sieve before chilling the mixture.
• Try adding a teaspoon of honey for a softer texture and deeper sweetness.
• If you enjoy citrus, a few strips of orange zest steeped with the tea take this recipe in a refreshing direction.

How to Make Homemade Earl Grey Ice Cream

Start by warming your milk in a medium saucepan over low-medium heat. Once it begins to gently simmer, remove from the heat and add your Earl Grey tea bags. Let them steep for about 5 minutes, giving them a gentle squeeze with a spoon before discarding to capture every bit of flavor.

Stir in the sugar until fully dissolved. If the milk has cooled too much, place it back over low heat briefly to help everything blend.

Pour in the heavy cream, vanilla extract, and salt. Stir to combine, then transfer the mixture to a heatproof bowl set over an ice bath to cool it down faster, or just refrigerate it for at least 2 hours (or overnight if prepping ahead).

Once chilled, follow your ice cream maker’s instructions to churn the base. This usually takes about 20 minutes, but every ice cream machine is a little different—check your manufacturer’s instructions.

Once the mixture reaches a soft-serve consistency, transfer it to a freezer-safe container. Press a piece of plastic wrap directly onto the surface to avoid ice crystals. Freeze for 3–4 hours, or until firm enough to scoop.

Pairings for this Earl Grey Ice Cream Recipe

You can pair this ice cream with many baked goods, such as those flavored with vanilla, orange, mandarin, honey, pumpkin, lemon, pear, or even chocolate!

Here are some delicious and complementary flavors that pair well with the sophisticated taste of Earl Grey:

1. Lemon: The citrusy tang of lemon complements the bergamot flavor in Earl Grey tea perfectly. Add a drizzle of lemon curd or some candied lemon peel on top of your ice cream for a refreshing and zesty twist.
2. Honey: The sweetness of honey is the perfect complement to the slightly bitter taste of Earl Grey tea. 
   Drizzle some honey on top of your ice cream or even swirl it into the mixture before freezing for a luscious and indulgent dessert.
3. Lavender: The floral notes of lavender pair beautifully with the bergamot flavor in Earl Grey tea. 
   Add a sprinkle of dried lavender buds on top of your ice cream or even infuse your cream with fresh lavender for an extra pop of flavor.
4. Dark chocolate: The rich and complex flavor of dark chocolate pairs surprisingly well with the subtle taste of Earl Grey tea. 
   Add some chocolate shavings or even a drizzle of melted dark chocolate on top of your ice cream for a decadent and sophisticated dessert.
5. Caramel: The buttery sweetness of caramel is the perfect complement to the creamy texture of ice cream. 
   Drizzle some homemade caramel sauce on top of your Earl Grey ice cream for a rich and indulgent treat.

Troubleshooting

Here are some potential troubleshooting issues that could arise:

1. Ice cream not freezing: If you find that your ice cream isn’t freezing in the ice cream machine, chances are the mixture is too warm. 
   Simply chill the mixture in the fridge for a bit longer, and make sure your ice cream maker is properly chilled as well.
2. Earl Grey flavor too weak: Are you finding that your ice cream doesn’t have the strong Earl Grey flavor you were hoping for? Try using more tea leaves, or steeping them for longer in the hot milk mixture.
3. Ice cream too icy: If your ice cream is turning out too icy, it may be due to not enough fat in the mixture. Make sure you are using full-fat cream and milk.
4. Ice cream texture is too grainy: If your ice cream has a grainy texture, it could be due to undissolved sugar. Make sure the sugar is properly dissolved before refrigerating the mixture

Frequently Asked Questions

How do I store my homemade ice cream?

Store your ice cream in a freezer-safe container in your freezer. Make sure your ice cream is well covered to avoid any ice crystallization.

If your airtight container lid does not close too well, add a piece of plastic wrap between the container and the lid, then close it.

How long will my homemade ice cream last in the freezer?

Your homemade ice cream will last in the freezer for around 3 months, but it will stay fresh for around six weeks. After that, the flavor may start to change, and your ice cream might loose its scoopable consistency.

Can I use loose tea leaves instead of the tea bags?

Sure, you can! Just make sure you pass the dairy mixture through a fine mesh sieve to get rid of the Earl Grey tea leaves that are loose.

Earl Grey ice cream is a unique and delicious dessert that pairs well with a variety of flavors and textures. Here are some recipe ideas that will make the perfect accompaniment to your homemade Earl Grey ice cream:

Follow this link for more Ice Cream and Frozen dessert recipes!

Follow me on Instagram and tag #sweetfixbaker to see all the recipes you make!

If you like this recipe, be sure to leave a comment and give it a star rating below!